Wednesday, August 2, 2017

The Semi-Attached Couple is like Jane Austen But With Extra Added Snark

As a longtime fan of Jane Austen, I'm always sad that she only completed six major works. There are far, far too many books claiming to be the heir to Jane Austen.  Somewhere in my bookish searches, I found The Semi-Attached Couple and The Semi-Detached House by Emily Eden, a Victorian writer who is largely unread these days. These two novellas are out of print but available for free online or inexpensively as used paperbacks, and are one of the closest things I've come to next-generation Jane Austen. 

My edition was published in one volume, and though the novels have similar names, they are unrelated. The Semi-Attached Couple concerns two neighboring families, the Douglases and the Eskdales. They had children about the same time, but as the children have grown, the families have grown apart, and Lady Eskdale, higher socially, has married her two daughters off before Mrs. Douglas, who is full of hilarious snide comments, much like Mrs. Bennet from Pride and Prejudice, only with a sharper tongue. 

In the beginning of the novel, the youngest and most beautiful Eskdale daughter Helen is about to be married to Lord Teviot, who is considered quite a catch. Helen is young and her expectations of marriage are different than those of her husband, which creates friction in their new marriage. He's jealous of her affection for her family. One thing leads to another and the marriage appears doomed. There are also side plots about unmarried friends and family and who's going to end up with whom. 

Also, soon after their honeymoon, her husband invites a large party to visit his estate, including the treacherous Lady Portmore. Here's an excerpt of a conversation between her and the newlywed Lord Teviot. Lady Portmore is trying to stir up trouble between Lord T and his bride: 

Lady P:  “Is that Helen's new horse she is riding?"

Lord T:  "No; Miss Forrester is on Selim."

[Lady P]:  "Well, I wonder Helen did not prefer your gift. I am sure that from sentiment I should never allow any human being but myself to ride a horse that had been given to me by the person I loved best in the world.

Lord T:   "That is an interesting and romantic idea; but as I shall probably have the honour of furnishing Lady Teviot's stud to the end of our days, it is not very likely that she will refuse to lend a horse to her friends when they come."

Lady P:  "Oh dear, no, that would be selfish; and you know how I hate selfishness. I often say there is nobody thinks so little of self as I do. Still I wonder Helen did not ride Selim."

Lord Teviot was silent.

Lady Portmore is everyone's best frenemy. She reminds me of a cross between Caroline Bingley from Pride and Prejudice and Mrs. Elton from Emma (with just a hint of Lady Catherine de Bourgh). There are a lot of similarities between these two novels and Jane Austen's works, and there's even a mention of P&P in a letter, from young Eliza Haywood asking permission from her mother to be allowed to read it. Clearly, Emily Eden was a fan of our Jane.

Naturally, all goes right in the end, with some good plot twists. I did wait a bit before reading the second novella, The Semi-Attached House, which I also enjoyed.  I was going to review both books in the same post but this has gotten longer than I expected so I'll save it for another day. These works don't have nearly the depth or the great writing as Jane Austen, but for plot, characters, and wit, they are just the thing if you are a Janeite or if you're looking for light Victorian read.


  1. Okay, that looks really entertaining. That is going right on my TBR pile.

    1. I loved it and also The Semi-Detached House.

  2. The first time I read these two, I liked The Semi-detached House much better. But I've really come to appreciate this book. I so wish Emily Eden had written more novels! But I really enjoyed her letters, which are also *very* Austenesque.

  3. I definitely want to read these two novels, thanks for the review, Lady Portmore sounds like a definite frenemy. I am on an Anthony Trollope reading odyssey now, lots of romances in the 1860s in them.

  4. I love books like thanks for posting about them. Now I can look for them online. :)

  5. You've really made me want to read this again, I remember loving it, but can't remember much else about it at the moment.

  6. Have you read Claire Harman's (excellent) book Jane's Fame: how Jane Austen conquered the world? She writes about Emily Eden as one of the women writers in the 1800s who "borrowed" from J.A., in part because Jane Austen's books began to be forgotten very soon after she died. I still haven't read these, tho I've had the green Virago edition for ages. But I want to!!

  7. I've had this book on my to-read list for awhile, but I haven't bought it yet. I'll have to add it to my list of books to look for when I go on my birthday book buying spree!

  8. Yay--you had me at Jane Austen. Defiantly going onto my TBR pile--once you find something that works for you, but then you think you've run out, its so good to findout there's more!

  9. How fascinating! I have heard nothing of these two books, and they sound well worth the time. Thanks for sharing them!

  10. You've sold it to me! Adding to tbr list. Thanks for the review!


Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.